Should students brainstorm alone or with help?

Most students benefit from a mix of independent reflection and guided conversation. Brainstorming alone allows students to explore thoughts freely without outside influence, which is important for authenticity. At the same time, gentle support from parents or mentors can help students articulate ideas they may struggle to recognize on their own. The goal of help is not to suggest topics or polish ideas, but to ask questions that spark reflection. When done well, collaborative brainstorming feels supportive rather than directive, and students retain ownership of their stories while gaining clarity and confidence.