AS SEEN ON
- Do all New York private schools ask for a proctored writing sample?Nope, not all of them. Some New York schools love the proctored writing sample, especially the ones working with Test Innovators. Others? Not so much. It really depends on the school’s admissions philosophy. Schools like Riverdale, Horace Mann, and The Spence School often use it to see how your child writes under time pressure, with no help from Grammarly, ChatGPT, or Mom. However, many schools still lean on student essays or graded work instead. Always check each school’s specific requirements, because assuming every school wants the same thing is like thinking every pizza place in New York uses the same crust. They don’t.
- What is the difference between student essays and on-demand writing samples?Student essays are the polished, well-fed, beautifully dressed versions of your child’s writing. They’re the kind you edit, revise, and sometimes agonize over for days. On-demand writing samples, on the other hand, are the pajama-wearing, caught-off-guard cousins. These are written during a timed session, often via Test Innovators, with a prompt your child sees for the first time and only 30 minutes to respond. No edits, no re-dos—just raw thinking on the page. Both give admissions officers insight, but one shows what your child can do with time and help, while the other reveals how they think on their feet.
- Are writing requirements different for middle school versus high school applicants?Generally, yes. The older your child, the more writing they're expected to produce. Middle school applicants usually get shorter prompts, fewer essays, and sometimes a single statement about who they are or what they enjoy. High school applicants, though? They’re often writing multiple essays, tackling big questions, and are expected to show deeper self-reflection and stronger writing mechanics. Some high schools even ask for graded essays or optional supplements. The good news is, younger students aren’t penalized for being, well, younger. Admissions teams know the difference between a 5th grader and a 9th grader—and they’re not looking for a college thesis from either.
- Can a student reuse one essay for multiple private school applications?Yes... But tread carefully. While some schools ask broad questions that lend themselves to repurposing, others want very specific responses. Reusing an essay word-for-word is fine if the prompt is nearly identical, but always double-check that it actually answers the question being asked. You don’t want to submit a heartfelt letter about why your child loves chess... to a school that asked about a favorite community tradition.Also, personalization matters. Schools can spot a generic “copy-paste” job a mile away. So sure, reuse the bones if they’re solid—but dress them up a little differently depending on who’s coming to dinner.
