Understanding High School Waitlists: What Parents Need to Know

The high school admissions process can sometimes stress you with an unexpected twist: being waitlisted. If your child has been waitlisted, you’re probably wondering what it means, what your chances are, and what you can actually do about it.

The good news? A waitlist isn’t a rejection. It means your child met the school’s criteria, but there weren’t enough seats available. Schools keep waitlists as a way to manage last-minute shifts in enrollment—so spots do open up. The not-so-good news? There’s no guarantee, and each school handles its waitlist differently.

So what now? Do you wait and hope, or is there something you can actively do to increase your child’s chances? The answer is both. Having gathered advice from our very own admissions experts, we’ll discuss how waitlists work, how to stay on a school’s radar, and how to navigate this nerve-wracking process without losing your sanity.

What Does It Mean to Be Waitlisted for High School?

High school waitlists exist when more students apply than there are available spots. Schools place some applicants on a waitlist rather than rejecting them outright. You’re probably wondering, What are the actual odds of getting in? The truth? It depends. But here’s a rough breakdown:

  • Super competitive schools (think elite private or specialized public schools): 5-15%
  • Selective but not insanely competitive schools: 15-30%
  • Less competitive schools: 30-50%+

The biggest factor? How many students actually give up their spots. If a school has a long waitlist and barely any movement, the chances are slim. But if the school regularly sees shifts in enrollment, your odds go up.

Common Reasons Students Are Waitlisted

  • The school received more qualified applicants than expected.
  • Your child met the academic criteria but was not in the top selection.
  • The school prioritizes siblings, legacy applicants, or geographical location.
  • Admissions committees want to maintain flexibility in finalizing class composition.

Do Waitlists Move? How Often Do Students Get Off the Waitlist?

Yes, waitlists move—but unpredictably. Some students may receive offers in a few weeks, while others may wait months. Waitlist movement depends on:

  • Yield Rate: The percentage of accepted students who enroll. If fewer students enroll than anticipated, schools admit waitlisted students.
  • Attrition: Some admitted students may decline offers last-minute, creating openings.
    School-Specific Policies: Some high schools actively manage their waitlists, while others rarely admit students from them.

Waitlist Strategies: Steps to Take If You Were Waitlisted

Should You Accept Your Spot on the Waitlist or Apply to Other Schools?

Before making any decisions, research the school’s waitlist acceptance rate. Some schools admit only a handful of students from the waitlist, others take more, and some don’t. Even if the odds are low, we still recommend submitting a Letter of Continued Interest (LOCI), unless that school is not at the top of your list or you’ve learned that their waitlist is parallel to rejection. If so, then move on with other plans and consider other schools already. Other alternatives include:

  • Applying to schools with rolling admissions.
  • Exploring private or charter school alternatives.
  • Reapplying next academic year if needed.

How to Improve Your Child’s Chances of Getting Off the Waitlist

1. Respond to the Waitlist Offer Promptly

If your child gets waitlisted, the school will usually ask if you want to stay on the list. This is a crucial step—if you don’t respond, they might assume you’re no longer interested and remove your child from consideration.

Think of it like a restaurant waitlist. If you put your name down but don’t check in when they call you, they’ll move on to the next person. The same goes for schools!

As soon as you receive a waitlist notification, follow the school’s instructions to confirm your spot. This could mean filling out a form, sending an email, or calling the admissions office. Don’t delay—some schools have strict deadlines, and missing this step could mean losing a potential seat.

2. Write a Strong Letter of Continued Interest (LOCI)

Should you decide to stay on the waitlist, writing a LOCI can be a strategic way to be selected from the waitlist pool. It serves two purposes: one, to reaffirm your interest in the school, and two, to update them on new achievements. A LOCI is basically a “Hey, I’m still here, and I’m even more awesome now” letter.

This is also your chance to remind the admissions committee that you’re still all in—and to show them that you’ve been making moves since submitting your application. A well-written LOCI can’t guarantee you’ll get in—but it can remind admissions officers why they liked you in the first place and tip the scales in your favor. But how should you write one? You can read here for more tips on how to write a strong LOCI.

3. Strengthen Your Child’s Academic and Extracurricular Profile

Encourage your child to keep working hard in school—strong grades can show the school they’re a great candidate. Beyond academics, leadership roles and extracurricular activities (like clubs, sports, or community service) can make a difference. If your child earns an award, takes on a leadership position, or achieves something impressive, let the admissions office know!

Think of it like a job application—if a company is still deciding between candidates, showing continued success and improvement can give your child the extra edge they need to move up the list.

4. Seek Additional Recommendations

Some schools allow students to submit extra recommendation letters, and this can be a great way to strengthen your child’s application. If allowed, consider asking a mentor, coach, teacher, or even a community leader who knows your child well and can speak to their strengths in a fresh, meaningful way.

The key is to choose someone who can highlight qualities that might not have been fully covered in the original application—like leadership, resilience, creativity, or a strong work ethic. A glowing letter from a trusted adult can help reinforce why your child deserves a spot at the school.

5. Consider Admissions Consulting

Seeking assistance from an admissions consultant can be a great choice if you were turned down by an Ivy League university and need direction on your next actions. These experts can offer individualized comments on your application, enabling you to understand what might have gone wrong and how to improve your profile for future prospects. They have a great deal of knowledge of the college admissions process.

Why Choose Cardinal Education?

Whether your focus is on transfer applications, appealing a decision (if the school permits it), or getting ready for another application round, an admissions consultant may provide strategic advice on enhancing your essays, extracurricular activities, and general placement. 

If you’re looking for expert guidance n, Cardinal Education can provide the personalized support you need. We’re here to take the stress off your plate and help your student put their best foot forward. Let’s figure this out together—give us a call!

Like what you see here? We are happy to permit you to use our material as long as you link back! Please refer to us as the Cardinal Education Blog.

Related Articles 

Waitlisted But Still Hopeful: How to Write a Strong Letter of Continued Interest

How Admissions Consultants Support Elite Admissions

Frequently Asked Questions

  • The waitlist process can take weeks or even months. Some students get off the list quickly, while others may not hear back until summer, just before school starts. Schools first wait to see how many accepted students enroll. If spots open up, they offer them to waitlisted students. There’s no set timeline, so it’s important to stay patient. Meanwhile, keep checking in with the school (without overdoing it) and explore other options. Some schools move through their waitlists quickly, while others rarely admit waitlisted students. If you haven’t heard back by mid-summer, it’s best to move forward with another school. Always have a backup plan to ensure your child has a school to attend in the fall.

  • No, being waitlisted actually means your child was a strong candidate. It means the school liked their application but didn’t have enough spots available. Many top schools get more applications than they can accept, so they place some qualified students on a waitlist. This allows them to fill openings if accepted students decide to go elsewhere. It’s not a rejection—it’s more like a “maybe.” Your child still has a chance of getting in. If the school didn’t think they were a good fit, they would have been rejected instead. Staying on the waitlist and showing continued interest can help improve their chances of getting admitted if a spot opens up.

  • Yes! First, confirm with the school that your child wants to stay on the waitlist. Then, write a Letter of Continued Interest (LOCI), thanking them and explaining why your child still wants to attend. If your child has achieved anything new—like better grades, awards, or leadership roles—mention it in the letter. Schools want engaged students, so staying involved in academics and extracurriculars is important. Some schools allow an extra recommendation letter from a teacher or mentor. Finally, check in with the school occasionally but don’t overwhelm them with messages. A polite email every few weeks is enough. While waiting, have a backup plan so your child is prepared for all possible outcomes.

  • Yes! Waitlist spots are never guaranteed, so it’s smart to secure another school option. If your child gets into another good school, accept the offer and pay any required deposits. If they later get off the waitlist at their top-choice school, you can decide whether to switch. Just be aware that some deposits may not be refundable. Schools don’t always admit waitlisted students, so it’s risky to rely only on one option. Having a backup plan ensures your child has a place for the next school year. If your child is accepted off the waitlist, you can decide what’s best for your family at that time. Always plan ahead to avoid last-minute stress.